Skip to main content

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo [Foreign]

I don't get it.

The movie is based on the book of the same name written by the late Swedish author Stieg Larsson. It's part of a trilogy of novels that has sold over 23 million copies worldwide. Everytime I walk into a Chapters or an Indigo, it's always on the bestsellers shelf/rack. So two weeks ago I sat at the bookstore for about an hour and started reading it. I got to around page 40 or so but the book never captivated me. It's just a straight up thriller/mystery story, what's the sell? I just don't get it.

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo is a Swedish produced thriller that follows an unlikely pairing of characters. The first is Mikael Blomkvist, a middle-aged journalist stuck in the middle of a controversy between his magazine company and a rich industrialist. He is hired by a rich old businessman named Henrik Vanger to solve a missing persons case, that of his beloved niece who has disappeared for 40 years. In exchange for his work, Vanger offers Blomkvist financial backing for the fledgling magazine company and evidence to prove his innocence amidst the controversy. He is aided by Lisbeth Salander, a young bisexual, cyberpunk girl. Together they work to unravel the mystery behind Vanger's niece and the Vanger dynasty.

In the end, the movie was alright, but certainly nothing to write home about. I enjoy thrillers as much as the next person but it just seemed to me that there was nothing that warranted all the acclaim that the book/movie was receiving. I think I had the same problem with this as I did with The Davinci Code movie. The stories are completely different but both are still highly acclaimed books. Yet with both movies, I just felt too much exposition; too much telling us what's happened instead of showing us what's happened. I think it works well in a book format as the whole adventure is created in our imaginations but I just don't think that style works with movies which are trying to show us the adventure.

That said, the movie was beautifully shot and produced. I think I enjoy foreign movies because it is a complete escape, from locale to language to culture. This is only the second Swedish movie I've ever seen (with the first being Let the Right One In) and I'm still impressed with their quality of production.

It's still in select theaters right now, so if you enjoyed the books, I suppose you couldn't go wrong with the movie. Otherwise, that's it for this week. Until next time, later geeks!

Comments

Slapinions said…
Whoa. Weird coincidence here: I'm nearing the end of the book and got a little spooked, so I decided to put it down and hit the web.

I thought the book started horribly slow and was quite tedious. In many respects it reminded me of a self-indulgent novel I wrote and abandoned about five years ago. The author of 'Tattoo' wrote these in his spare time for fun, and I think they would have been leaner and more captivating if he'd written w/ an audience in mind.

So for 200 pages I was bored - I told someone it was like watching paste dry - but committed. Then slowly, slowly, slowly, I actually started to *care* about the mystery. I think it is largely due to the sheer weight of all the background you're given on the characters; you're forced to care by default.

Now, 100 pages from the end I can admit to being legitimately spooked at the idea of heading to the dark basement to retrieve a load of laundry.

So, 1st half of the book: C-/D
2nd half: A -
Total: good enough to pick up the 2nd book
The Lam said…
Hey Dan,

Thanks for the input, I appreciate hearing from someone who's read/reading the book.

So is the book or series worth the phenomenon that the media is making it out to be? Because the movie didn't make it seem that way, and since from what you say of a C-/D first half for the 1st half of the book, doesn't make it sound worthy of all the acclaim.
Slapinions said…
1st, apologies for my spelling in this comment. I'ts late.

Honestly, while I wound up liking the book, all the hoopla and praise seems surreal. Stylistically it's clumbsy, the pace is slow, and (having now finished it) the book continues on for more than 50 pages AFTER the mystery is concluded!

I disliked Da Vinci, but I could see why others would enjoy it. I'm not sure why this wasn't left on the shelves gathering dust.

I don't know. All those points against it and I'm still going to borrow the next book from the library. So who knows - maybe the author made a pact with the devil to win fans. It worked for Stephanie Myers :)

Popular posts from this blog

Mark Waid's IRREDEEMABLE (Issues #1-7)

(Note: be warned that this review is on the spoiler heavy side, so read at your own discretion if you don't want the story spoiled.) Since I was a teenager, I always had this dream that I would become a quirky movie director and I'd make a bunch of crappy little horror movies to start with, but that my first big movie would be this anti-superhero movie. I dreamed up of an Apocalypse Now -like movie using existing Marvel superheroes where Captain America would go mad, slaughtering the innocent and go into hiding somewhere 'up the river'. There would be a detective like character (possibly superhero) that would be after him, interviewing his former teammates to find out what made the all-American hero go mad. Imagine my surprise when I started reading Irredeemable . Although not exactly the story in my dreams, it's pretty close. I started reading the series this past weekend upon the glowing review that those geeks over at iFanboy put up a few weeks ago. As far a

Call of Duty: Black Ops 3!!!!!!!!!!!! (PS4)

Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 is Activision’s latest entry into the bestselling Call of Duty franchise.  Developed by Treyarch Studios, the Black Ops subseries of Call of Duty games has been considered by many as the best of the COD games.  Whereas Black Ops 1 and 2 were direct sequels, BO3 seems only to be a spiritual sequel to its predecessors.  There is no direct or clear continuation of story from the previous entries.  Rather it takes the ideas of mind control and manipulation, and spins off its own story. It’s a futuristic world, where humans are infused with technology (much like Robocop!) and fight alongside and against robots.  This time around, you assume the role of an unnamed soldier, who together with your partner Hendricks and a CIA agent named Rachel Kane, track down a former Black Ops commander named John Taylor as he and his former squad appears to have gone rogue destroying CIA sites around the world.  The story will take you to Singapore, Egypt and ev

The League of Denial (2013)

The topic of concussions in sports is a dialogue that’s been growing the past number of years.  Do a search on ‘concussions’ and ‘football’ and you’ll get several thousand hits on the controversy that’s surrounded the sport.  It’s a challenging topic as the research is all relatively new, and the topic itself challenges the mentality and philosophy adopted by football loving Americans.  Now, I’m not a fan of football or NFL but when I saw this book lying at the local bookstore, my interest was piqued.  Although I’m not a fan of football, those that know me know that I’m an unabashed fan of prowrestling.  Talks about concussions are also quite a hot topic even within the prowrestling sub-culture.  Earlier this year, one of the hottest wrestlers of the current era, Daniel Bryan, retired early at the age of 34 due to a history of concussion related issues.  Interestingly, he was not permitted to return to the ring due to the disapproval by WWE’s medical director – a doctor by the name